AI Blind Test

Peloton vs Mirror

Which brand does AI prefer? We tested both across 3 leading AI models.

AI GEO Score

Based on 3 AI models and 5 evaluation angles

61%

MIRROR

39%

Share your GEO Score

Show your competitors who AI prefers

Why AI Prefers Privacy Policy

Gemini 2.5 Flash

Company A (Peloton) projects stronger trust due to its detailed and comprehensive privacy policy, indicating transparency and a well-established legal…

GPT-5 Mini

Peloton (Company A) presents a broader, more mature ecosystem—multiple hardware lines, extensive app features, integrations and explicit data/feature…

Gemini 2.5 Flash

I would go with Privacy Policy (Peloton) because they offer a wider range of dedicated fitness equipment (Bikes, Treads, Row, Guide) and a more establ…

The AI Verdict

Split decision: Gemini 2.5 Flash favor Privacy Policy, but GPT-5 Mini give the edge to MIRROR. The biggest gap is in innovation — Privacy Policy scores 8.4 vs MIRROR's 6.9.

Sentiment Breakdown

How each website scores across key dimensions (1-10)

Privacy PolicyMIRROR

Trust & Authority7.7 vs 7.1

Innovation8.4 vs 6.9

Price Competitiveness5.5 vs 5.7

Ease of Use6.8 vs 7.5

Per-Model Verdicts

How each AI model independently evaluated the two websites

GPT

GPT-5 Mini

Prefers MIRROR41 vs 59

“Peloton (Company A) presents a broader, more mature ecosystem—multiple hardware lines, extensive app features, integrations and explicit data/feature details—making its value proposition and capabilities clearer. lululemon Studio/Mirror (Company B) offers a compelling mirror-based experience and membership perks, but hardware availability is limited and the offering now hinges largely on a content partnership with Peloton, reducing its independence and long-term clarity.”

GEM

Gemini 2.5 Flash

Prefers Privacy Policy79 vs 21

“Company A (Peloton) projects stronger trust due to its detailed and comprehensive privacy policy, indicating transparency and a well-established legal framework around data handling. Company B (lululemon Studio) also has privacy and warranty documents, but the provided content is more promotional and less indicative of deep operational transparency.”

CLD

Claude 3.5 Haiku

Tie50 vs 50